Book Review: Original City, Original Sin: King, the Klan, and the Fight for Civil Rights in St. Augustine, Florida
Martin Dobrow’s highly engaging chronicle of America’s “oldest city,” St. Augustine, relays the promise and heartbreak of the Civil Rights Era in equal measures. A well-conceived microhistory that captures the mood of the entire nation during this highly charged period of history, Original City proves that a thoughtful writer can narrate the past at the same immersive “first draft” pace that characterizes prize-winning journalism. While Dobrow frequently reflects on his story’s high-stakes implications, he doesn’t limithis gaze in order to advance a narrow academic argument. Instead, he creates a compelling narrative, a plot- and character-driven account of how ordinary Black (and white) citizens of St. Augustine, aided by a handful of activists and journalists from other parts of the country, changed the course of history between the spring of 1963 and the summer of 1964.
Nonetheless, in light of recent resurgences of white supremacy and Christian nationalism, readers can’t help but be struck by his story’s disturbing echoes with the events and trends of the present. The racist fervor of the Klan, with its tactics of intimidation and mob violence, plays a key role in shaping Dobrow’s account. Similarly, the political intransigence and willful ignorance and indifference of St. Augustine’s so-called moderates, which served the segregationists’ cause as effectively as the Klan’s campaigns of terror, can’t help but remind readers of the climate of political dysfunction that allows hate to fester in our own time.



Comments