top of page

Book Review: Orig­i­nal City, Orig­i­nal Sin: King, the Klan, and the Fight for Civ­il Rights in St. Augus­tine, Florida

Oct 12
1 min read

Mar­tin Dobrow’s high­ly engag­ing chron­i­cle of America’s ​“old­est city,” St. Augus­tine, relays the promise and heart­break of the Civ­il Rights Era in equal mea­sures. A well-con­ceived micro­his­to­ry that cap­tures the mood of the entire nation dur­ing this high­ly charged peri­od of his­to­ry, Orig­i­nal City proves that a thought­ful writer can nar­rate the past at the same immer­sive ​“first draft” pace that char­ac­ter­izes prize-win­ning jour­nal­ism. While Dobrow fre­quent­ly reflects on his story’s high-stakes impli­ca­tions, he doesn’t lim­ithis gaze in order to advance a nar­row aca­d­e­m­ic argu­ment. Instead, he cre­ates a com­pelling nar­ra­tive, a plot- and char­ac­ter-dri­ven account of how ordi­nary Black (and white) cit­i­zens of St. Augus­tine, aid­ed by a hand­ful of activists and jour­nal­ists from oth­er parts of the coun­try, changed the course of his­to­ry between the spring of 1963 and the sum­mer of 1964. 


Nonethe­less, in light of recent resur­gences of white suprema­cy and Chris­t­ian nation­al­ism, read­ers can’t help but be struck by his story’s dis­turb­ing echoes with the events and trends of the present. The racist fer­vor of the Klan, with its tac­tics of intim­i­da­tion and mob vio­lence, plays a key role in shap­ing Dobrow’s account. Sim­i­lar­ly, the polit­i­cal intran­si­gence and will­ful igno­rance and indif­fer­ence of St. Augustine’s so-called mod­er­ates, which served the seg­re­ga­tion­ists’ cause as effec­tive­ly as the Klan’s cam­paigns of ter­ror, can’t help but remind read­ers of the cli­mate of polit­i­cal dys­func­tion that allows hate to fes­ter in our own time. 


Comments


bottom of page